HomeMy WebLinkAbout1985-10-21 Council MinutesCost of Application
Roadside Weed Control Program 1986
Norman Soder
October 21, 1985
The cost of custom application of herbicide on roadsides varies
from $45 00 to $60 00 per runninq mile, both sides The area covered would be
approximately 6 acres
The cost of application of herbicide on roadsides with our own
roadside sprayer would vary according to the factors that we used These factors
would be number of miles of roadside sprayed, recovery of investment over what
period of time and maintenance The fixed costs would be operation costs and these
could vary depending on the number of road miles sprayed
The cost of application varies also when you blanket spray as compared to patch
spraying
Our present truck and sprayer cost the M D $12,000 00 in 1974
Roadside spraying costs to the M D have only been maintenance and operational costs
I would expect that $2 00 per mile sprayed, both sides, would cover this
For Grant purposes we have been claiming $32 95 an hour This cost
includes travel time from the shop spraying, travel between spray areas and travel
time back to the shop Spraying at 12 M P H we would be costing this out at
$32 95 divide by 6 miles equals $5 50 per mile both sides This would not include
travel time
Should you want to recover the cost of an $80,000 00 spray unit
over a period of 10 years, you would have to claim $8,000 00 per year This
would vary at cost per mile, depending on the number of miles sprayed per year
Should you spray 1,000miles per year your cost for recovery would be $8 00 per mile
Five hundred miles per year would increase your cost to $16 00 for recovery of
investment
Choice of Herbicide (Based on 6 acres per mile both sides)
Tordon 22K
$87
00
per acre
$522
00
per
mile
Tordon 10K
$81
30
per acre
$487
00
per
mile
Desermone
$ 6
00
per acre
$ 36
00
per
mile
2 4 - D
$ 6
00
per acre
$ 36
00
per
mile
Desermone and 2 4 - D would only give top growth control For Toad Flax or Canada
Thistle yearly spraying would be required
Tordon lOK Pellets could be applied with a half ton truck and spreader There could
be some complications with this The cost would be minimal
Patch Spraying
The cost of Tordon 22K per mile would vary as to the number of patches
per mile Our total cost has been anywhere from $30 000 00 to $35,000 00 over
the past few years This is why we have claimed grants on a per hour basis
Recommendation
Any amount of blanket spraying with Tordon would almost be out of
the question as it would be too costly There are approximately 50 miles per
Township at $522 00 for Tordon plus application would amount to $26,400 00 per
Township
Prior to the development of Tordon the recommendation for the control
of Toad Flax, was to seed the area to grass and keep the Toad Flax growth burnt
back with 2 4 - D It was assumed that this would eventually deplete the Toad Flax
l;i
Con't
con It
Roadside bleed Control Program 1986
Estaprop 600 g/1 gave very good top growth control of Toad Flax
at 1 1/acre in our plots at Hoppins Desermone is exactly the same product with
a heavier concentration of 2 4 - D and Dichlorprop 700 g/1
I would recommend that we blanket spray, with Desermone, a 12 mile
border on the north side and the west side of the M D This would cover
approximately one half of the M D Approximately 1,000 miles or 6,000 acres
Desermone cost would be approximately $36 000 00 The cost of application would
be over and above this cost, approximately $9,000 00 for a total of $45,000 00
The balance of the year could be spent patch spraying the south and east portion
of the M D with Tordon 22K for the control of perennial weeds, mainly Canada
Thistle The application costs would be greater than the herbicide costs at this
time as there are very few patches of perennial weeds in this area
I would also recommend that any farmer who was willing to make a
concentrated effort to control Toad Flax on his private land, that upon request,
we blanket spray the ditches bordering his property with Tordon lOK Pellets
Our roadside spraying program for the control of weeds on new
construction has been in effect for a number of years It appears to be quite
satisfactory
Each year we blanket spray all new construction for three consecutive
years with 2 4 - D and Torch Each year we drop of the construction that was
completed four years prior to the year of spraying and add on the previous
years construction This gives the grass three years to become established
It appears that three years is a sufficent length of time for weed control
This control is mainly for annual weeds
Another herbicide that could be used for blanket spraying would br Tordon 101
Tordon 101 $24 00 per acre $144 00 per mile
This application at 2 81 per acre would amount to 24 oz of 2 4 - D and 6 oz
of Picloran per acre
List of miles in M D of Kneehill
Secondary Unopen
4
00
miles
Local Unopen
218
22
miles
Local Dirt
425
19
miles
Secondary Gravel
51
22
miles
Local Gravel
1,056
83
miles
Oiled Secondary
55
95
miles
Oiled Local
50
75
miles
Paved Secondary
81
10
miles
Paved Access
8
50
miles
TOTAL 1,951 76 miles
-----------------
-----------------
This does not include Highway #21, twenty -eight miles or Highway #27, fifteen
miles Highways take responsibilty for weed control on these roads
1,951 76 miles X 6 acres sprayable per mile = 11,710 56 acres
Keep in mind the number of acres that the average farmer controls weeds on
each year and what his average cost might be
Also, we know what Tordon 22K will do we are unsure of Tordon 101 or Desermone
Desermone worked good on a dry year